en • 3 min read
By Raphael Schön
01.04.2019
Right, you took the bait and thought that Bitpanda was now buying and selling tulips. Or maybe you didn’t. But anyway, what’s the deal with tulipmania and Bitcoin? Is there really a parallel to be made between the two, as countless articles and analyses have suggested?
Right, you took the bait and thought that Bitpanda was now buying and selling tulips. Or maybe you didn’t. But anyway, what’s the deal with tulipmania and Bitcoin? Is there really a parallel to be made between the two, as countless articles and analyses have suggested?
Conventional thinking has it that the 17th century Dutch obsession with tulips (the so-called “Tulip mania”) offers a nice historical comparison for understanding the rise of Bitcoin and cryptocurrency in general. We are told how “tulip mania”, the first speculative bubble, created a situation in which the price of tulip bulbs skyrocketed 200 times over a four-year period, peaking in February 1637 before prices quickly plummeted, with the bulbs becoming all but worthless.
In fact, tulips have become synonymous in finance reporting with extreme asset price deviations. If there’s a hint of a bubble bursting, then there’s likely a tulip analogy not far behind.
Heads of legacy institutions appear to be the biggest sceptics — and the most frequent purveyors of the tulip analogy. Take comments made by the former president of the Dutch Central Bank, Nout Wellink: “Sooner or later the facade will fall”. Wellink has even called bitcoin “pure speculation” and “hype”. JPMorgan CEO Jamie Dimon has said that bitcoin is a fraud: “It’s worse than tulip bulbs. It won’t end well. Someone is going to get killed”. Nobel Prize-winning economist Robert Shiller has commented that bitcoin reminds him of tulip mania. Nouriel Roubini called Bitcoin the “mother of all bubbles”, and “much worse” than the tulip bubble.
But the bubble has already burst. According to Anne Goldgar, a Professor of Early Modern History at King’s College London, who has written a book on the subject (Tulipmania: Money, Honor and Knowledge in the Dutch Golden Age), any talk of a link between tulip mania and a Bitcoin bubble is misguided and even misinformed. As she has argued in her essay “Tulip mania: the classic story of a Dutch financial bubble is mostly wrong”:
“It was not actually the case that newcomers to the market caused the crash, or that foolishness and greed overtook those who traded in tulips. But this, and the possible social and cultural changes stemming from massive shifts in the distribution of wealth, were fears then and are fears now. Tulip mania gets brought up again and again, as a warning to investors not to be stupid, or to stay away from what some might call a good thing. But tulip mania was a historical event in a historical context, and whatever it is, Bitcoin is not tulip mania 2.0.”
The journey is just beginning. It’s important to remember that a cryptocurrency such as Bitcoin is still in its infancy. Although it might be hard to believe, it is in fact only ten years old! Far from a temporary phenomenon, cryptocurrencies, and technology like blockchain that underpins them, are full of unrealised potential across many industries and applications. With their increasingly widespread availability, cryptocurrencies are more omnipresent today than ever before. By any measure, ‘the Bitcoin experiment’ is a striking success.
Knowledge is power. And the Bitpanda Blog aims to provide its readers with the latest information to enable them to make the best decisions regarding their assets and investments.
Bitpanda GmbH ve grup şirketleri (Bitpanda) Türk Parasının Kıymetini’nin Korunması Hakkında 32 sayılı Karar’ın 2/b maddesine göre Türkiye’de yerleşik sayılan hiçbir kişiye yönelik olarak 6362 sayılı Sermaye Piyasası Kanunu başta olmak üzere Türkiye Cumhuriyeti Devleti mevzuatı hükümleri gereği Türkiye’de faaliyet izni gerektiren hiçbir sermaye piyasası faaliyetine dair hizmet sunmamaktadır. Şayet Bitpanda’nın yabancı sermaye piyasalarında vermiş olduğu hizmetlerden Türkiye’de yerleşik kişilerin faydalandığı tespit edilecek olursa tüm zararları kullanıcıya ait olmak üzere bu hizmetler ivedilikle sona erdirilecektir.
We use cookies to optimise our services. Learn more
The information we collect is used by us as part of our EU-wide activities. Cookie settings
As the name would suggest, some cookies on our website are essential. They are necessary to remember your settings when using Bitpanda, (such as privacy or language settings), to protect the platform from attacks, or simply to stay logged in after you originally log in. You have the option to refuse, block or delete them, but this will significantly affect your experience using the website and not all our services will be available to you.
We use such cookies and similar technologies to collect information as users browse our website to help us better understand how it is used and then improve our services accordingly. It also helps us measure the overall performance of our website. We receive the date that this generates on an aggregated and anonymous basis. Blocking these cookies and tools does not affect the way our services work, but it does make it much harder for us to improve your experience.
These cookies are used to provide you with adverts relevant to Bitpanda. The tools for this are usually provided by third parties. With the help of these cookies and such third parties, we can ensure for example, that you don’t see the same ad more than once and that the advertisements are tailored to your interests. We can also use these technologies to measure the success of our marketing campaigns. Blocking these cookies and similar technologies does not generally affect the way our services work. Please note, however, that while you’ll still see advertisements about Bitpanda on websites, the adverts will no longer be personalised for you.